Ingratitude. A noun. The state of being not grateful.
This was one of the vocabulary words today. I thought I could count on the students to discuss for a few minutes what they were grateful for. (Look! I ended a sentence in a preposition! see yesterday’s post).
Instead, I began the day with Mary asking, “What’s grateful mean?” As I tried to hide my original feeling of surprise, which quickly turned to incredulousness, and ended with complete and utter angst that a student would not know the word grateful, another student nonchalantly came her rescue.
“It means thankful,” Scott interceded.
A student helping another student is not anything new. When I was a student, I had one group project, and it was in my freshman English class. We created a slide show of whales using a 35 mm camera and slide film. Then, we found a song of whale sounds to accompany it. This was our symbolic interpretation of Herman Melville’s Moby Dick. I am not sure of my grade, but I doubt it was good since I am still in freshman English. Of course, all of my other teachers made us work by ourselves.
Over the last twenty-three years of my career, teachers have tried to incorporate teamwork and collaboration into lessons. As a freshmen teacher, I have had to deal with students being able to get to get together with classmates outside of school. I have also had to deal with one kid being a slacker, one person doing all of the work , and, of course, the one who could only give orders or negative feedback. Next, I had to explain my logic in the grades to the parents. The group project usually ended up with the parent, the student, and myself unhappy and full of ingratitude for the lesson.
I have found the best collaborative lessons to be similar to the impromptu lesson this morning: a student helping a student. I can expand on the lesson by having each student in a group create a clause to use in a sentence with a vocabulary word or individually revise a paragraph then team up with others to discuss the best revision ideas or have a small group create thoughtful questions for a socratic discussion.
All of these ideas do not require time outside of class, nor do they require a complicated rubric to make sure everyone does his or her share. These lessons require me to listen and observe. It is not a perfect system, but neither is the work place. There are committees or work groups everywhere that have slackers or people trying to make others look bad. The lack of productivity will catch up with the person. If a person hardly does any work on his or her own, I would be skeptical that he or she suddenly becomes the model student or employee when in a group.
The best collaboration brings out ideas or leads to more questions. It is not always about producing a project or product.